Welcome to Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den
At Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den, nostalgia meets culinary innovation. Nestled in the heart of Newtown, CT, this vibrant eatery expertly blends the cherished flavors of classic pizzas with a modern twist. Guests rave about the unique offerings like the French Onion and the Heat Of The Moment pies, which highlight quality ingredients and creative combinations. The cozy, eclectic decor transports visitors back to the '80s and '90s, creating an inviting atmosphere perfect for gathering with friends. Paired with a thoughtfully crafted cocktail menu, Good Old Days is truly a gem where every visit feels like a delightful trip down memory lane.
-
19 Main St, Newtown, CT 06470, United States Hotline: +1 203-491-2920
Welcome to Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den, a delightful culinary gem nestled at 19 Main St, Newtown, CT. This cozy eatery has quickly captured the hearts of food enthusiasts and casual diners alike, thanks to its compelling combination of expertly crafted pizzas and innovative cocktails, all set within a warm, eclectic ambiance.
As you step inside, the nostalgic décor reminiscent of the '80s and '90s invites you to linger, evoking fond memories while modernizing the dining experience. The atmosphere is both lively and intimate, making it an ideal spot for gatherings with friends or a casual date night.
At the heart of Good Old Days lies its impressive menu focused on pizza, offering a limited but thoughtfully curated selection that showcases their mastery in this art. From the Heat Of The Moment—a tantalizing blend of red sauce, mozzarella, sopressata, red onion, bomba calabrese, and a touch of honey—to the uniquely crafted La La Land featuring buffalo chicken and creamy buttermilk blue cheese, every slice is a hit. It's no surprise that the French Onion Pizza has garnered rave reviews, making it a must-try specialty.
- Thin and Crispy Pies: Try the Heat Of The Moment or the savory La La Land for an unforgettable flavor journey.
- Square Pies: The Vodka and Big Mood options elevate the pizza game with rich toppings and homemade sauces that come together beautifully.
- Salads: Complement your pizza with innovative salads like Kale and B’nut Squash or Shaved Cabbage and Winter Greens, both bursting with flavor.
The feedback from diners reflects a shared sentiment of excitement and satisfaction. Customers like Chad Carvey have dubbed dishes like the Bikini Bod pizza as "one of the best" they've ever had, praising its unique flavor profile. Meanwhile, Michelle Humann emphasized the importance of trying what some might consider "weird" pies—the French Onion undoubtedly topped her group’s favorites. Each review underscores one common theme: the quality ingredients and skilled preparation shine through in every bite.
Beyond the pizzas, the cocktail offerings shouldn't be overlooked. The drink menu features creative concoctions that pair perfectly with the vibrant dishes, offering an enriching experience that caters to both the palate and sensibilities. Customer Corey Ferrell captured this perfectly, noting how the cocktail program is among the best, seamlessly complementing the stellar pizza selections.
In conclusion, Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den is not just a restaurant but a charming destination that expertly balances nostalgia with culinary innovation. Whether you're returning for a favorite pie or exploring the diverse menu for the first time, you're set to be impressed. With every visit, you may discover a new slice of happiness undoubtedly worthy of your time. So, if you find yourself in Newtown, make it a point to enjoy the ambiance and flavors—you won't regret it!
We had always heard great things about Good Old Days and their French onion pizza specifically, but WOW. We were beyond impressed! I think it’s great that they have a more limited menu focused on the pizza so that they can master what they do well. Loved the vibe - it was cozy but eclectic. Staff was great! We warmed up here after a night at the igloos at the nearby winery, so it really hit the spot. We’ll be back because the French onion is in the top 5 best speciality pizzas I’ve had in CT!
Got the Bikini Bod. One of the best pizzas I've ever had. The combination of the ricotta and sesame seeds and honey almost give a bagel flavor and the crust is absolutely perfect, crispy and crunchy in all the right places.
My new favorite pizza place! Great atmosphere and great service. Highly recommend.
I have to say pizza was great. Sauce tasty, still crisp, dough nice. Got the thin cheese pizza. I was 30 minutes late picking it up. Wish I had been there on time. Cool little place inside as well. I will be back.
Great little spot with amazing pizza and salads. Not to mention their homemade desserts! This little place has it all! We were not disappointed one bit! Don't be afraid to try their 'weird' sounding pies! That French Onion square pie was the hit from our group! My favorite was the Heat of the Moment. All was delicious! Get there early. They get pretty packed!
Such a cool place! I ordered the French Onion pie, which was very good! All their pizzas are pan pizzas, which I absolutely love (don't get me wrong, NH-style is great but not superior to any other pizza style). I had a chance to talk to the pizza guys, who were very kind and fielded a bunch of my weird questions about their ovens, prep, etc. The atmosphere was really cool - a neat place to hangout with friends. It has the same kind of dark cozy atmosphere as the Dew Drop Inn in Derby, if you're familiar. Highly recomended!!
This was a surprising gem I found by accident. I literally pulled in their parking lot just to make a U-turn and saw the inconspicuous entrance. As soon as I walked in, I felt the atmosphere of never wanting to leave. Very warm atmosphere with decorations of the 80s and 90s to bring me back to my late teens and hanging out with my friends parent's basement. Had the La La Land pizza, which was quite unique with the vodka sauce and fresh basil. If I actually live in the area, this would be my weekend hangout!!
Been back here a few times and it is AWESOME! Because - they have Sicilian style (square, thick crust) and crunchy, which is uncommon. I grew up in NYC and while you could certainly find this style, it typically did not have crispy crust. The toppings and flavors are delicious. In the photo, you will see their really cool ricotta kisses - a treat for the eyes and palate. Their cocktail program is among the best we've encountered. There are few places that combine outstanding pizza with killer mixology - G.O.D. does the spirit world justice! One of the photos shows the G.O.D.s mai tai 3.0 - cachaca & mezcal - are you kidding?! Desert - House-made choco-taco, dipped in dark chocolate. Oh yeah! The only comment I have for the owners: Friday night, there was a duet playing which is a great add to an evening but the din was deafening! The place was packed and with the music, it was impossible to carry on a conversation. The acoustics are hard - below grade with plenty of hard, reflective surfaces. Would be even more awesome with some absorption/diffuser panels tacked up.